Some of us are old enough to recall an October 20, 1969 statement by the then Vice President of the United States, Spiro Agnew which was spoken in context of a speech denouncing the Moratorium Day protest against the Vietnam War: “A spirit of national masochism prevails, encouraged by an effete corps of impudent snobs who characteristic themselves as intellectuals.” (en.wikiquote.org) Sadly the statement was not made as a challenge to open dialogue between those who were passionately against continuing United States military involvement in Vietnam and those who were just as passionately in favor of continuing that involvement or who argued that it is was in the national interest to do so. Had it been made as a respectful challenge instead of yet another effort to silence those opposing the war, it could have possibly helped some of us to accept a kernel of truth and be more open to dialogue. From the vantage point of age and hindsight many of us passionately opposing the United States action in Vietnam and surrounding countries including Cambodia were indeed arrogant and self-righteous. In fact, we were not only arrogant and self-righteous, but, as I now recall, a group of mostly white males who, in a very sexist manner, welcomed the assistance of mostly white females. We might have, in time have incorporated more of the principles of Martin Luther King Jr. but when Vice President Agnew made this statement, no matter how mean spirited its seeming intent, he was, in some measure. accurate.
Today in 2017 Anthony Van Jones*says something similar about both the so called left and the so called right. In his new book, Beyond the Messy Truth: How We Came Apart, How We Come Together, he suggests that both sides learn to respectfully listen and hear each other. Although the book is just now available and, thus, I have not read it, he said in an interview that both sides can be very arrogant which, of course, prevents hearing each other which, in turn, prevents working together. This is not an exact quote as I heard parts of the interview while I was driving. Still, I am eager to read the book and to take what he says to heart. He is one of those all too rare individuals who honesty believes that everyone counts. While his beliefs resonate with me because I share them, I am also aware that in my heart of hearts I find it all too easy to convince myself that I would be happy to dialogue if certain people I label as those on the “right” who I think have little regard or respect for non-white, non-heterosexual, non-male, non-so called Christians would lay down their swords and make it safe to approach them. In other words, I often still find it easier to point fingers than I do to examine my own behavior. While I profess to believe that all count, I find it very easy to pretend that I am a very limited understudy for the performers of Saturday Night Live and can make fun of those with whom I passionately disagree without disrespecting them or their opinions. Excuse me! Did I just say that? Indeed, I did. If I continue to believe that I have 100% of the truth pertaining to any issue and “you” have zero percent of the truth about that issue, I am going to continue to either initiate or join in the stone throwing contest.
The bottom line is that I would do well to focus on my behavior and the extent to which it is or is not matching my stated beliefs instead of what “the other” is doing. In fact, as soon as I label someone as “the other” I have shut down all possible dialogue.
I am eager to receive and read Mr. van Jones’ book. Yet, I do not need to wait until then to keep bringing the focus back to my imitation of a member of “the effete corps of impudent snobs. In fact, it may be time to retire my tea shirt which says “Proud Member of the Effete Corps of Impudent Snobs.” While some might still find it cute it clearly labels me a part of the problem and not part of the solution.
Written October 7, 2017
*Van Jones is a social entrepreneur, CNN political contributor and host of The Messy Truth with Van Jones. Famous for his heart-felt election night coverage, Jones showed up as “the voice of reason” for people in red states and blue throughout the volatile 2016 political season. In response to much civil unrest and energy post election, Jones launched the #Love Army -- a values based movement that is working for an America where everyone counts.Jones has founded and led numerous social enterprises engaged in social and environmental justice.” Vanjones.net