Recently I was listening to Fresh Air host, Terry Gross, interview the comedian ‘Ramy’ Youssef. As a young Muslim he must decide whether he will allow his Muslim elders to dictate the rules which they believe God requires Muslims to follow or whether he will make decisions based on what makes sense to him. He humorously called the decision to choose and follow those which make sense to him “Allah care”. Today, as I was driving from Canton, Texas to Dallas, Texas I was listening to an episode of Hidden brain on which host Shankar Vedantam talks with Psychologist Hal Herzog about the question of why we eat some animals and have others as pets. Dr. Herzog discussed the fact that our decisions often elude scientific examination. For example, the life of the chicken which will end up as a meal is most often filled with physical and, we must assume, emotional pain while the life the animal used for cock fighting which has been outlawed in the United States and elsewhere is often qualitatively much better. The cock rooster is often treated with great love and respect even though it is also trained to fight. Dr. Herzog offers many more examples of the contradiction in our ethical decisions which we will often defend even knowing, at some level, that our defense cannot pass the simplest scientific test.
If we make decision based on what makes scientific sense we are often ridiculed and labeled as sinful, immoral or unethical. If we are choosing to not follow a religious rule which does not make sense someone may quickly remind on that the God of their understanding is not going to be pleased and many even punish one for all of eternity. For example, “Ramy” Youssef chooses to not drink alcohol but does choose to have responsible/protected sexual relationships outside of marriage.
I am well aware that I pick and choose the religious or ethical rules which either make scientific sense to me or which I justify because I am no yet ready to give up a practice I enjoy. I do, for example, choose to eat chicken, pork, beef and fish even though I am fully aware that I may be participating in or supportive industries which mistreat those animals Although if given the choice I will choose free range chicken over industry chickens and other meat products from a local farmer, I also know that I make compromises when the choice is not affordable or easily available. I am also aware that I choose to be a pacifist while honoring the decisions of veterans and, as a veteran, taking advantage of the medical services of the Veterans Administration.
I suspect most of us are A la carte shoppers which it comes to our ethics. Sometimes our choices are carefully thought out based on our understanding of what makes the most sense given what we now know. Often our choices are based on what is most comfortable for us or perhaps the least offensive. I choose to use Apple products. In fact, I have probably been heard to say “I love my Apple products.” Yet, I have also been heard to say that “I attempt to buy products from companies whose ethical treatment of employees is good as far as I can determine.” Truth be told I know that Apple has not always put the needs of workers first. I am currently not sure how much they are policing contractors and sub-contractor’s employee policies and practices.
There was a time when many of us believed that we could “know” what companies were treating employees with respect, but we soon found out that if we were going to live on the grid we were deluding ourselves.
Living off the grid is not an option I am pretending to choose today. Although, in the past, I lived in intentional communities where it was easier to make some decisions about how much to participate in the larger economic and social community, even then we were making choices about medical care for our children or the use of other services based on our immediate comfort and convenience.
Once again, I am reminded that spiritual growth is a process and not a destination. I am also reminded that I need people in my life who challenge the ethics or morality of my decisions based on my professed beliefs or intentions. I am well aware that I have no answers but do have some goals of humility and honesty. I would like to find ways to live more harmoniously with other people and mother. I would also like to be less judgmental of the choice’s others are making. As Robert Frost would say, “I have miles to go before I sleep.”
Written June 30, 2019
Jimmy F Pickett, LPC, AADC
Coachpickett.org