Surprise! While at the gym this Friday morning I was listening to the latest On Being podcast with host Krista Tippett. This week her conversation is with historian and Harvard professor, Annette Gordon-Reed and artist Titus Kaphar. The title given to their conversation is “Are We Actually Citizens Here?” They are asking this question from the vantage point of living as African Americans (I defer to their right to identify themselves as such although I have an issue with using the word American as a synonym for the United States. Obviously, the United States is just one of the Americas.) but they are also asking a broader question about immigrants, Native American, those who have been convicted of certain crimes and no longer have the right to vote, women, members of the LBGT community and all of those to whom we give lip service to the title of citizen.
It seems to me that as we approach July 4th or Independence Day it is not only appropriate but necessary to ask this question. Historically, we have formally denied full citizenship to many including those we decided were Negro or black even though many, if not most, also had white ancestors; all females who for many years were not allowed to vote, own property or claim other rights granted to adult males deemed to be white; members of the GLBT community who until relatively recently would often be locked up in prison or forced into treatment to change them; to anyone who had the misfortune of being convicted of a particular crime when the primary crime may have been not being able to afford a good attorney or being someone the judge saw as more likely to be guilty; immigrants who may not have the money or other resources to jump through the hoops to become citizens, or those who first settled these lands, the Native Americans.
I am perfectly willing to grant full citizenship to those so-called business people who do not honor legal agreements, who use bankruptcy laws and very good attorneys to avoid honoring debts and other agreements. I am perfectly willing to honor the citizenship of those who have raped the land and destroyed communities or otherwise made a profit off the backs of other men and women. I am perfectly willing to grant citizenships to those who make a lot of money by keeping wages and other benefits low and then donating a lot of money to some “worthy cause” because this allows them to morph into community saints, benefactors or philanthropists. I am perfectly willing to honor the citizenship status to those who use “illegals” to care for their children, clean their bathrooms and other rooms of their homes, mow their lawns, pick their crops and do other tasks most of us do not want or do not have to do.
I am perfectly willing to honor the citizenship of those whose money got them elected to a position which includes gold quality health insurance, but vote to refuse health care to millions of others while recommending that we spend billions more on weapons to destroy those we label as the enemy even though there is no evidence that such actions bring long term peace and a more just world.
I am even willing to honor the citizenship of those who take advantage of the “market” to keep people from being able to afford decent (in some cases any) housing while the very same landlords buy a vacation house or two.
I am even willing to honor the citizenship to CEOs and other top officials of pharmaceutical companies and presidents of colleges who make millions while raising the price for their goods or services higher and higher thus making them unaffordable for many.
I am willing to honor the citizenships of those who feel so disenfranchised that they support politicians who seem unable to treat anyone who disagrees with them with a modicum of decency.
I am a proud citizen who applauds the freedom to honor the citizenship status of all those who comprise the community living in these United States. Yes, I too, claim full citizens’ rights and privileges. I am well aware that there are many countries whose leaders could have me imprisoned for publicly announcing that “The Emperor has no clothes.” I am grateful for living in a country where I am free to challenge who we are as a nation and, thus, ask who is a citizen. At the same time, I know that as Heraclitus said, “You cannot step into the same river twice.” Either we go forward in walking the walk and talking the talk regarding citizenship or we go backwards.
(Although the On Being conversation between Ms. Tippett and her guests, Dr. Gordon-Reed and Mr. Kaphar inspired me to write the above, these are my words, not theirs. I urge the reader to listen to the podcast of their challenging and inspiring conversation.)
Written June 30, 2017