Most of us are well aware that truth is a relative matter dependent on many factors. For example:
- One can spin the truth to show, at best, a partial truth.
- One can deliberately lie because one is frightened of telling the truth.
- One can deliberately lie to gain some monetary, political or other goal.
- One can misinterrupt what someone said or did ; assume what one saw or heard was accurate or the entire story.
- One can deliberately lie because the listener does not want the truth or it would be unkind to tell the truth.
- One can be delusional, paranoid or in a hallucinatory state.
- One can mistake a belief for the truth or deliberately present a belief as the only possible truth, I. e. religious beliefs.
- One’s brain can trick one because of some past traumatic experience.
- One can assume one is seeing or hearing one thing when in fact they are only seeing or hearing a portion and are consciously or unconsciously filling in the rest.
Children frequently learn at a very young age that parents lie when they say they “just want the truth”. For example. if a parent asks a young child why they ate candy when they knew it was so close to dinner time they do not want the child to tell them, “I wanted candy instead of dinner you dummy!” As the child enters puberty most parents do not want the child to say they snuck out at night because they wanted to have amazing sex with a peer! A parent or a teacher might say, “Just tell me the truth. I won’t get mad.” The child knows this is a lie. Often the parent or teacher will be very angry if the young person tells the truth.
As we approach or enter adulthood we learn many euphemisms to hide the lie in a magic trick. For example, one may learn how to market or brand a product in a way that presents only the positives. If, as in the case with drug side effects or the fine points of a contact, the negatives are presented they are minimized in some way or embedded in a pleasant photo or soothing music.
Politicians also gear their political speeches to appeal to a particular audience. Truth or their portion of the truth may change from speech to speech.
One can also contradict the truth by labeling it “fake news” or by directly or indirectly discrediting the messenger or attempting to discredit the person or persons who is the subject of the alleged news item.
Most of us do not deliberately lie or consciously mislead others. We may, however, not be very discerning about what we label as “the truth”. Perhaps we could all benefit from reminding ourselves:
- We can only share or report our truth as we currently understand it.
- Sharing with others our process for deciding when a source is more likely to “fact check” as best as possible before passing it on.
- Staying open to the possibility that we are the ones with fake news or, at best, only a portion of what might be accurate.
- Placing information in context rather than sharing out of context information.
- It is important to be as honest as possible while also realizing that becoming honest is a lifelong process which may require peeling back many layers.
- There are many ethical and moral beliefs about most subjects. Talking about our beliefs about what is moral or ethical is much different than talking about the truth about what is ethical or moral.
- We need to be clear that about what we heard or saw which is different than reporting that we heard or saw as the truth.
I am not suggesting that approximating a truth upon which some or even most of us can agree is easy or comfortable. I am suggesting that it may be well worth the discomfort or difficulty to search for the kernel of truth around which we or someone else may have written a page or even a book of fantasy.
Written February 28, 2019
Jimmy F Pickett
Coachpickett.org