For several years I was a member of the Racial Justice committee at the YWCA in Wheeling. I have also been blessed to be a member of other groups whose goal was to examined not whether, but in what ways I and other members had learned to be racist, sexist, homophobic or otherwise discriminatory and oppressive.
One of the first exercises the members of the Racial Justice Committee members were asked to do was to write about one’s earliest memory of being racist. We had to repeat this exercise several times and then read what we had written to the rest of the members of the committee. The first time I wrote I described an incident when I was about 5-year-old. I had done something which I knew my mother would not approve. When she questioned me about it I very deliberately blamed the boy of the same age with whom I was playing. I knew, at age 5, that because the other boy was black my mother would believe me and not him. I also knew at age 5 that my behavior was not right. I am not sure how I knew the later, but I clearly felt guilty. In my memory, the guilt began as soon as I lied to my mother. The guilt about the racism was clearly more than the guilt about lying. In fact, as I recall, it seemed reasonable to me to lie since my mother’s anger could be very frightening. Although my lying seldom worked I knew it in this instance it would work.
By age 5 or perhaps earlier I also “knew” that women were inferior to men; that it was wrong to be attracted to the same sex; that boys who were not willing to physically fight were sissies; that “those people” included “foreigners, Native Americans and anyone who was different. Additionally, I had learned that it was shameful to be financially poor. I also had learned that it was okay to kill one’s enemy and that only bad people were in jail.
At the same time, I knew that in church I was taught to love one’s enemy unless; that God loved “those people” as long as they stayed on their side of the track; that only protestant Christians were going to heaven; that poor people did not deserve to go to college; that some women were professional and to be respected, but they were still responsible for children, cooking and maintenance of the home. Women were to be respected because they were weak and fragile. Girls learned how to take care of children by playing with dolls. Boys learned to play with trucks and weapons.
In short, learning “truths” started when one was very young. Yet, many of these truths conflicted with my simple interpretation or understanding of the lessons I was learning in Sunday School. Even some of those did not make sense. I was not very old before I also noticed Aunt Bullah was a minister and seemed happier and kinder than most male ministers and some of my peers who came from “wealthy” families who had new cars, televisions and electricity were not very nice.
The members of the Racial Justice Committee assumed that all people – male, female, white, black, brown, college educated or not – had learned to be racist, sexist, homophobic, and otherwise discriminatory/oppressive. It was our job to practice getting honest with ourselves so that we could identify some of the lies we had learned and begin to correct those lies.
When someone says to me that they are not racist, sexist or otherwise discriminatory I am very confused. I am not convinced that it is possible to grow up in the United States or most other countries and not learn many lies based on race, gender, age, nationality, religion, culture, or ableness.
When someone says that many have become too sensitive or too politically correct I suspect that what they mean is:
- Often many of us more concerned about pointing out how wrong or bad others are rather than focusing on problem solving or looking at our own oppressive behavior.
- The goal is to punish and not teach.
- One may be concerned with saying the currently accepted language rather than “walking the talk”.
We do, I believe, need to be clear that all of us
have internalized many lies about ourselves and others we would do well to unlearn. We do, I believe, have to work together to find creative ways to more quickly create a more equal, just society and to “treat” the direct and indirect effects of the history of unequal treatment and opportunity. We can do this humility and kindness while also being clear that discrimination and oppression is simply not acceptable.
Written August 20, 2018